Copy-trading test: Binance top 10 lost 12.6% over 16 days
A Reddit r/CryptoCurrency poster reports running a simulated $5,000 copy-trade on the top 10 traders from three platforms' 30-day leaderboards starting at the Nov 2 close. At the Nov 18 close, the Binance top 10 group was down 12.6%, Hyperliquid top 10 vaults down 25.3% and OKX top 10 down 28.9%, versus -19.6% for holding BTC and ETH. The poster says two traders carried the Binance group, that 7 of the 10 closed their portfolios within two weeks and that the middle trader was down 80%, and discloses building Botsfolio.
Market around the story
| Asset | Price at first report | 1h before | 1h after | 6h after | 1h move vs normal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BTC | $62,137 | +1.0% ! | −0.08% | −0.58% | 0.2σ |
Returns are measured from the moment the story first appeared. “vs normal” compares the move with the asset's typical hourly move over the previous 30 days.
Why “Rumor”
- Only community or trader posts: r/CryptoCurrency
0 independent source groups across 1 post · evidence score 9/100. How labels work
What the sources claim
-
The poster's simulated Binance top-10 copy-trade group fell 12.6% over 16 days, from $50,000 to $43,702.
“Binance top 10: -12.6%** ($50,000 is now $43,702)”
r/CryptoCurrency -
The Hyperliquid top-10 vaults in the test lost 25.3%.
“Hyperliquid top 10 vaults: -25.3%”
r/CryptoCurrency -
The OKX top-10 group in the test lost 28.9%.
“OKX top 10: -28.9%”
r/CryptoCurrency -
Simply holding BTC and ETH over the same period returned -19.6%. BTC
“Just holding BTC + ETH: -19.6%”
r/CryptoCurrency -
Seven of the ten Binance traders closed their portfolios within two weeks.
“7 of the 10 closed their portfolios within two weeks.”
r/CryptoCurrency -
The median of the ten Binance traders was down 80%.
“The middle trader of the ten is down 80%.”
r/CryptoCurrency
Sources
More on BTC
Embed this page
Summary and claims extracted by AI with prompt analyze-story@5 on 2026-11-20 07:20 UTC. Labels are computed from the sources, not by the model.