Backtest compares buying strong stocks vs laggards during market dips
A Reddit r/stocks post reports a backtest of two dip-buying strategies on the 500 most traded US stocks from February 2018 to September 2026, using SPY at least 2% below its 3-month high as the weak-market trigger. The author reports that stocks beating SPY by 5+ points and closing at a 50-day high averaged +0.60% over 20 trading days versus +1.10% for random stocks, while laggards that fell 5+ points behind and closed at a 50-day low averaged +1.57% versus +1.04%. The author states the laggard edge shrinks to +0.16 points against volatility-matched random stocks, with a 95% range of -0.23 to
Why “Rumor”
- Only community or trader posts: r/stocks
0 independent source groups across 1 post · evidence score 9/100. How labels work
What the sources claim
-
The author tested dip-buying strategies on the 500 most traded US stocks from February 2018 to September 2026.
“I tested both on the 500 most traded US stocks, Feb 2018 – Sep 2026”
r/stocks -
Stocks that beat SPY by 5+ points and closed at a 50-day high averaged +0.60% over 20 trading days versus +1.10% for random stocks.
“Average +0.60% vs +1.10% for random stocks”
r/stocks -
Stocks that lagged SPY by 5+ points and closed at a 50-day low averaged +1.57% versus +1.04% for random stocks.
“Average +1.57% vs +1.04%”
r/stocks -
Against volatility-matched random stocks the laggard edge was +0.16 points with a 95% range of -0.23 to +0.56, not different from zero.
“the gap is +0.16 points (95% range -0.23 to +0.56), so not different from zero”
r/stocks -
The worst trades in the test were three US banks in March–April 2023, down 100%, 100% and 95%.
“Worst trades: three US banks in March–April 2023, -100%, -100%, -95%”
r/stocks
Sources
More in Stocks & Indices
Embed this page
Summary and claims extracted by AI with prompt analyze-story@5 on 2026-11-17 07:20 UTC. Labels are computed from the sources, not by the model.